Song Critique
Clear, honest feedback to help you finish stronger songs.
A second set of trained ears helps cut through familiarity bias and reveal issues you’re too close to hear.
What this service is (and isn't)
This is
Objective, experience-based feedback on your song
Focused on songwriting, arrangement, production, and mix priorities
Clear notes you can act on immediately
This isn’t
Generic praise or vague opinions
A full mix, master, or rewrite
Trend-chasing or changing your artistic direction
How It Works
Step 1 — Submit your track and any notes or goals
Step 2 — I review the song in detail
Step 3 — You receive structured feedback within 48-72 hours
- Feedback is based on your goals, not what I think your music should sound like
Pricing
Song Critique
(Written)
79
$79
NZD
Detailed written feedback
—
Your choice of notes on:
– Songwriting/Composition
– Lyrics/Story Arc
– Mix/Production/Recording
– Song Structure/Flow/Arrangement
—
Personal input where relevant
—
48–72 hour turnaround
Song Critique
+ Voice Note
99
$99
NZD
Detailed written feedback
—
Same notes as previous tier
—
Personal input where relevant
—
10-15 minute voice note:
– Clear explanations & context
– Why things work or don’t
– Audio demonstrations
—
48–72 hour turnaround time
Live Song Feedback
(30 min)
149
$149
NZD
Written notes included
—
Live feedback & discussion
—
30 min video call with:
– Playback
– Q&A
– Call recording provided
Prices in NZD. Converted automatically at checkout.
Feedback is based on your stated goals, not personal taste.
Live sessions are subject to availability and time zones.
All feedback is subjective by nature.
Who this is for
This service is best suited to:
►Modern rock & metal musicians
►Guitar-driven artists working in a DAW or MIDI composition tool
►Songwriters refining demos or final tracks
►Artists who want clarity rather than validation
- If you’re still learning basic DAW or composing fundamentals, this may not be the best use of your money yet.
Delivery & expectations
Feedback is honest, constructive, and goal-focused
Turnaround time: 48–72 hours
All files and links remain private